My girlfriend (the lovely Nicole) pointed out that I haven't posted here in quite awhile, and she's right. I have no excuses and no apologies. The comics will have to wait for another post, but I've got yer book talkin' right here.
Basket Case
by Carl Hiassen
There's nothing more uncomfortable to read than an old, rich, white dude trying to write about rock 'n roll. I'm sure it can be done properly, but music is a young man's game and the elderly (and even those slightly middle aged) had better know what they're talking about in more detail than a Harvard law grad knows his tort reform before they go wading to those murky waters.
Baby Boomers know the Beatles, the Who, the Rolling Stones, the Beach Boys and even the Clash, Sex Pistols and the Ramones. They write about these bands, quote these bands, reference these bands, and even adopt these bands' postures with commendable familiarity. Anything after that is a no-no. In "Basket Case," Carl Hiassen breaks these cardinal rules and if the world of American Letters were a mosh pit, he'd be the goofy dork on the edge in his $250 leather jacket and pressed pants. He can certainly show up and try to act the part, but we all know he should really be at home or out at the sushi joint around the block.
Hiassen's hero for this murder mystery could be pulled right out of the "How to Write a Best-Selling Mystery" handbook. He's a disgraced crack reporter with a nose for trouble and an ear for smart-assed dialogue. If you think this sounds like Mr. Irwin M. Fletcher of Gregory MacDonald's novels, you wouldn't be far off. Jack Tagger could be Fletch's long lost brother.
The murder to be solved in this little piffle of a book is that of James Stomarti AKA Jimmy Stoma of the band, The Slut Puppies. It seems that after going into rehab, Mr. Stoma is about to make a comeback album. Nevermind that in the real world of music producing, no one could give two farts about an aging 80s rocker's comeback bid. And to Hiassen's credit, he addresses this honestly. None of the kids in the book have ever heard of Jimmy Stoma. It's the details he fails at. When a producer is painted as a bad-ass by having worked with Matchbox Twenty, I knew I was in for trouble. And though the book is set in the present day (circa the year 2000), MTV is portrayed as it was in the late '80s, as a station the kids turn to to actually see videos. This is obviously taking place in a fantasy world or the world of the hopelessly out of touch.
The mystery elements here are pretty creaky, too. We've got the usual ransacked apartments, midnight muggings, menacing bodyguards, money grubbing widows and smarmy music types. It's a yawn, and they feel like stock characters carted straight out a Columbo murder mystery.
The banter, which Hiassen, consciously or unconsciously seems to be channeling from Mr. MacDonald, is pretty good. It's no Fletch, but there are a few good zingers, a couple zappos, and one or two turds.
I need to give Hiassen some credit for being dead on with his knowledge of the newspaper game. He's been a journalist for 25 years and his descriptions of a reporter's life and the day-to-day life of the newsroom are all true and accurate. So good job for that, Carl! Now stay away from my music and go back to NPR!